Court of Appeals Logo

Republic Of The Philippines
Court Of Appeals

Return to CA Website

Recent Decisions And Resolutions

Disclaimer

The electronic content in this microsite may contain computer-generated errors or other deviations from the official printed documents. In case of discrepancies between the official print and electronic versions, the official print version prevails. Certified copies of the official documents may be requested from the Court of Appeals. Additionally, this list includes decisions and/or resolutions within the seven days leading up to and including the most recent release date.

Case Number Station Case Title Action
CR-49138
(January 20, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. GARIBALDI DAVID y JOSE

Case Number

CR-49138

Date

(January 20, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186065
(January 20, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

MAINE MARINE PHILIPPINES, INC., MISUGA KAIUN CO., LTD., AND/OR MA. CORAZON G. SONGCUYA VS. ROLDAN S. GONZALES

Case Number

SP-186065

Date

(January 20, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-187320
(January 20, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

AGATON R. BEJERANO, JR. AND JENNIFER ALEJANDRO VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES AND REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 46 URDANETA CITY, PANGASINAN

Case Number

SP-187320

Date

(January 20, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-113853
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

CHRYSOBERYL L. DACUNO, REY L. DACUNO AND ERNANE L. DACUNO VS. DE LA SALLE CANLUBANG, INC.

Case Number

CV-113853

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-121632
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

MARY GRACE G. MONTAS vs. SANDY O. MONTAS

Case Number

CV-121632

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-122019
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

IN RE: PETITION FOR ISSUANCE OF SECOND OWNER'S COPY OF TCT NO. T-129300 OF THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF CABANATUAN CITY; HILARIA CONCEPCION HERNANDEZ, REPRESENTED BY ATTY. ANGEL BENITO C. HERNANDEZ, ANGEL T. CONCEPCION,JR. VICTOR T. CONCEPCION, GEORGINA CONCEPCION PASTORFIDE, CRISOSTOMO T. CONCEPCION, MILAGROS T. CONCEPCION, REPRESENTED BY THEIR ATTORNEY-IN-FACT VICTOR T. CONCEPCION VS. THE REGISTRY OF DEED OF CABANATUAN CITY UNITED COCONUT PLANTERS BANK ( NOW LAND BANK OF THE PHILIPPINES) AND FELIPE T. CONCEPCION

Case Number

CV-122019

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-123523
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

AIMEE UY CHONG, vs. RICHARD CHUA CHONG,

Case Number

CV-123523

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-124232
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

JOSEPHINE ONG-CAYABYAB vs. ERIC P. CAYABYAB

Case Number

CV-124232

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-182596
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

MICHELLE E. BAYLON VS. NLRC (2ND DIVISION, PRESIDING COMMISSIONER, JULIA CECILY COCHING-SOSITO), ARANDREA MANPOWER SERVICES CO., / DOHA TORCH MANPOWER / SAFAA RIZON MOHAMED NEJEM / DANILO C. DEL CAMPO

Case Number

SP-182596

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-183834
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

C.S. ENRIQUEZ CSEMSCORP. (CONTRACTORS, FABRICATORS) INC., REP. BY TERESITA ENRIQUEZ VS. NLRC AND HENSLEY V. VALINO

Case Number

SP-183834

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-184035
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

APRIL MAULAWEN ALVAREZ VS. APLUS MANPOWER SERVICES, INC./JUICES FACTORY TRADING COMPANY/ARNOLD C. ALDAY AND NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (FOURTH DIVISION)

Case Number

SP-184035

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-185557
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

DAVID B. BARANDON VS. FIRST GLOBAL BYO CORP.,

Case Number

SP-185557

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-187696
(January 17, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ARTURA DECANO BULAGA a.k.a. ANNIE DECANO BULAGA VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES

Case Number

SP-187696

Date

(January 17, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-49536
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES -VS.- RANDY ARIZALA y HIROZANO

Case Number

CR-49536

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-19784
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES -VS.- KENNETH ISIDRO SALES, JR. y NARAG

Case Number

CR-HC-19784

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-12544-MIN
(January 16, 2025)
CDO

Case Title

Olarte Hermanos y Cia, represented by Arturo Olarte; and/or Arturo R. Olarte, in Own Capacity as Member/Shareholder of Olarte Hermanos y Cia versus The Hon. Presiding Judge/s, Branches 35 and 60, Regional Trial Court - General Santos City and Branch 14 - Regional Trial Court, Cotabato City, Espina and Madarang Company; Makar Agricultural Corporation; Oscar E. Noel; Roberto Urgello; Antonio E. Madarang; and Alfredo E. Madarang; and Other Persons and Entities who Deprived Title from Them; and El Hogar Filipino

Case Number

SP-12544-MIN

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

CDO
SP-167772
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PAQUITO C. CAUNIN VS. HEIRS OF THE LATE TRINIDAD FRANCISCO, NAMELY ATTY. EMMANUEL CAPINPIN AND LITA CAPINPIN ALMEDA, HEIRS OF ERLINDA FRANCISCO NAMELY CARLOS BELIZARIO, JOSE BELIZARIO, FE ALONTE AND ILDEFONSO BELIZARIO, JR., THE ONLY HEIR OF LEOPOL FRANCISCO, NAMELY JOSE MARIO C. FRANCISCO AND THE ONLY HEIRS OF VICTORIA FRANCISCO, NAMELY SOCORRO F. ALMEDA HEREIN REP. BY THEIR ATTY.-IN-FACT ATTY. EMMANUEL CAPINPIN AND ACTING FOR HIMSEPF AND SPS. WILBERT S RAMOS AND FLORENCE QUE-RAMOS

Case Number

SP-167772

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-172217
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

MAGSAYSAY MARITIME CORPORATION, FLEET MARITIME SERVICES INTERNATIONAL, LTD. AND/OR KRISTINE ABIGAIL BERENGUER VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (FIFTH DIV.) AND RUBY ESPINOSA REMIGIO-TUPAZ

Case Number

SP-172217

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-181442
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

AZTEC CONSTRUCTION EQUIPENT INC., VS. NLRC 6TH DIVISION, JOSE JURY LORDAN ESCONDIDAD, LEMUEL LARAWAN RODRIQGUEZ, JOVIT LAGARDO HIMAYA, ROLINDO MAHINAY CHAVEZ, JUNY AGAN MARUHOM, ELMER AREVALO DECENA, DANILO GARNICA ESPINA, JUNIE TAGAT GUIAPAL, JAYSON BOBIS PALERMO, JERAL BOBIS PALERMO, TONY HIPULAN PERIN, JOBERT PALERMO SIGUENZA AND MARIO ESMAIDE TAGAY GUIAPAL

Case Number

SP-181442

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-182453
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

MAKATI MEDICAL CENTER / MEDICAL DOCTORS INC., VS. NLRC, AND DR. RHODORA M. LEDESMA

Case Number

SP-182453

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186396
(January 16, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

VICTOR M. BORROMEO VS. JUANITO ALMOJERA

Case Number

SP-186396

Date

(January 16, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-116393
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

IN RE: PETITION FOR CANCELLATION OF ADVERSE CLAIMS IN TCT NO. 70343 OF THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF ANGELES CITY; SPS. ELENA S. BATAC AND RONALD C. DAVID, REPRESENTED BY THEIR ATTORNEY-IN-FACT, ANNALYN D. GUIAO VS. THE REGISTER OF DEEDS OF ANGELES, JULIETA NACPIL DELA PAZ, JOSE DELA PAZ, JR. AND MARVIN BATAC-REYTERAN

Case Number

CV-116393

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-120242
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES; ADESSA CORPORATION,

Case Number

CV-120242

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-49977
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. ANTONIO BELTRAN y MARTINEZ

Case Number

CR-49977

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-50174
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. NENITA BALADAD (ACCUSED-APPELLANT) & SPS. LAZARO BALADAD (DECEASED)

Case Number

CR-50174

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-20917
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. CICL JOHN REY RECINTO SAYAN

Case Number

CR-HC-20917

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-170176
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

(DELTAMECO CREWING SERVICES INC.) SUBSTITUTED BY BRIGHT MARITIME CORPORATION AND/OR IRIKA SHIPPING S.A. VS. RODOLFO P. MAGTANG

Case Number

SP-170176

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-171967-UDK
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

JTB DEVELOPMENT CO., INC. VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION AND ANTHONY LAJO CARILLO

Case Number

SP-171967-UDK

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-183382
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

GEORGE D. IGLESIA VS. THE HON. JOEL SOCRATES S. LOPENA, IN HIS CAPACITY AS THE PRESIDING JUDGE OF RTC BR. 80 QUEZON CITY AND JUANITA ESTER D. IGLESIA, ZAIDA D IGLESIA AND RODERICK D. IGLESIA

Case Number

SP-183382

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-187093
(January 15, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

CELEDONIO A. PILE AND MA. CHARINA S. GARCIA VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINE SUNWESTVILLE REALTY AND DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION,

Case Number

SP-187093

Date

(January 15, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-120723
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ASIA UNITED BANK CORPORATION vs. SQUARE METER TRADING AND CONSTRUCTION CORP., represented by its Chairman ALEXANDER CRUZ and by its President, LITO C. PASCUAL and LITO C. PASCUAL

Case Number

CV-120723

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CV-124044
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES, REPRESENTED BY THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS CORDILLERA ADMINISTRATIVE REGION (DPWH-CAR) VS. MARIA THERESA GACETA AND THE REGISTER OF DEEDS FOR BAGUIO CITY

Case Number

CV-124044

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-49209
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES -VS.- MARLON DELA CRUZ y BAUTISTA

Case Number

CR-49209

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-50503
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. DANDY PANGANORON y REALINGO, AND JAMAICO ALIDON y ALMODIEL

Case Number

CR-50503

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-17025
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. FEDERICO ANGINGAN y BERNARDO

Case Number

CR-HC-17025

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-18641
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES -VS.- RODERICK MARIANO @"Jepok"

Case Number

CR-HC-18641

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-18672
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES -VS.- ELEUTERIO DIAZ y GARCHITORENA

Case Number

CR-HC-18672

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
CR-HC-19103
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. JONARD FAJARDO aka "JAY-R"

Case Number

CR-HC-19103

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-10386-MIN
(January 14, 2025)
CDO

Case Title

Flavia Quinlob and Danilo Quinlob

Case Number

SP-10386-MIN

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

CDO
SP-12029-MIN
(January 14, 2025)
CDO

Case Title

People of the Philippines

Case Number

SP-12029-MIN

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

CDO
SP-131985
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ELOISA ELEAZAR, AND VIRGELIO ELEAZAR VS. OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN, AGHAM RD., DILIMAN, QUEZON CITY; PSI LODOVICO M. ELEAZAR, JR., PO2 JOMAR CAMAT, PO2 BILLY JOE COLLADO, PO3 PO3 ERWIN LOPEZ, BRGY., CAPTAIN LOPEZ, BRGY., CAPTAIN EDGAR M. ELEAZAR, AND BRGY., KAGAWAD ROGELIO E. LOPEZ,

Case Number

SP-131985

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-166920
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

LINO A. FERNANDEZ, JR., AS SUBSTITUTED BY HIS SOLE HEIR SARAH RAFLORES FERNANDEZ vs. NLRC, MANILA ELECTRIC COMPANY (MERALCO) MANUEL LOPEZ, RUBEN SAPITULA and HON. LABOR ARBITER MARIE JOSEPHINE SUAREZ

Case Number

SP-166920

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-174190
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

LUZ P. ARCILLA AND SPS. EDGARDO AND NILDA SANTOS, VS. LIRIO PAZ SABARRE, CHINA BANKING CORPORATION AND REGISTRY OF DEEDS OF QUEZON CITY

Case Number

SP-174190

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-177465
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

EDWARD HURANO MILLAN, MICHAEL M. MELLIZA, EDWIN M. DORIMON JR., BENJIE C. SUMBLON, JAYSON R. FONTELARA, LEUVINO M. QUILET, MERWIN C. ROS, RONNIE P. LAROGA, JAY ALBERT F. RAMOS, MARIO D. GERVACIO, PEDRO T. PONGCOL, JR. VS. NLRC 4TH DIVISION, MILLENIUM ERECTORS CORP. AND LAURENCIO TIU

Case Number

SP-177465

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-178496
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

INTEGRATED TECHNOLOGY AND PROCESS SOLUTION INC., EFREN JAPOR, RICARDO SY AND JOHNY TALANDRATA VS. NLRC 4TH DIVISION, ARGIE M. AGLIPAY, RON REXON S. DEL PILAR, CIPRIS RAMER V. DE GUZMAN, EDRIAN R. MALLARI, JOHN MICHAEL C. SILORIO, ANDREW D. PEREINA, LOUIE D. CALUMPIANO, DONATO R. BORRAS III , MELRICK M. GAMOSO, ZUES B. ROMERO, AND ERMARSON S. MOLINA

Case Number

SP-178496

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-183664
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PHILIPPINE PRECISION TECHNOLOGY INC. VS. OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY REP. BY THE HON. BUREAU OF LABOR RELATIONS (BLR) DEPARTMENT OF LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT (DOLE) INTRAMUROS, MANILA AND HON. UNDERSECRETARY BENEDICTO ERNESTO R. BITONIO JR. PHILIPPINE PRECISION TECHNOLOGY INC., WORKERS UNION-PTGWO REP. BY RAYMART D. CASTRO SAMAHAN NG MANGGAGAWA SA PHILIPPINE PRECISION TECHNOLOGY INC (SMPPTI-INDEPENDENT)

Case Number

SP-183664

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-183729
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES VS. HON. MELITA AMYLESHA G. DELSON-MACARAEG ASSISTING JUDGE OF RTC BR. 9 LA TRINIDAD BENGUET AND JOSHUA SALBENO ALKERA

Case Number

SP-183729

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-185377
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

FREDDIE CAMPO MALBUESO, NORBERT OCURA VALLEJO, AND ALEXANDER PALAPUZ SALES VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION (THIRD DIVISION), RYAN ROMAR TAXI AND MAGDALENA H. SANTOS

Case Number

SP-185377

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-185969
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ARIEL ALVIAR y GONZALES VS. MALABON CONTAINER CORPORATION

Case Number

SP-185969

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186134
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

RIVERFOREST DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION REP. BY ITS ESTATE AND SECURITY MANAGER, REYNANTE D. RAFAEL VS. SPS. AGUINALDO AND CLARISSA POBLETE, AND ALL PERSONS CLAIMING RIGHTS AND INTEREST UNDER THEM, HON. MA. LOURDES ELTANAL-IGNACIO PRESIDING JUDGE OF RTC OF DINALUPIHAN BATAAN, BR. 5

Case Number

SP-186134

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186486
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ALBERTO A. CALUBAQUIB, MARILYN K. CALUBAQUIB, ELEUTERIO A. CALUBAQUIB, FAUSTINO CALUBAQUIB, GAVINO MALAZZAB, REMEDIOS C. MALAZZAB, DANIEL D. DE GUZMAN, SR., LEONORA DE GUZMAN, JOHN MILTON TAGUINOD, VINCENT T. CALUBAQUIB, VS. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

Case Number

SP-186486

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186586
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

ZALDY TIMBAL VS. HON. MARIAM G. BIEN, IN HER CAPACITY AS PRESIDIN GJUGDE OF RTC OF TAGUIG CITY BR. 153 AND MARIA MENDOZA

Case Number

SP-186586

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA
SP-186812
(January 14, 2025)
MANILA

Case Title

JOHN PAUL S. STA. ANA, OSCAR C. BORJA AND RAYMUND HERMIE T. ODIADA VS. NATIONAL ELECTRIFICATION ADMINISTRATION REPRESENTED BY ITS ADMINISTRATOR ANTONIO MARIANO C. ALMEDA

Case Number

SP-186812

Date

(January 14, 2025)

Station

MANILA